This Soda Might Be Hard To Swallow
For a while now, gay people have been trying to deal with a response to DOMA... The Defense of Marriage Act. I've come up with it.
I think it's time for one of my elected representatives to introduce SODA: The Sexual Orientation Discount Act.
Here's the premise.
The conservative right spends an inexplicable amount of time and energy devising ways to shortchange gay men and women of their rights on the federal, state and local level. Depending on the issue and community, these efforts have either been partially or entirely successful. So, if our rights are to be discounted, our taxes should be discounted as well.
Here's how it works.
Each right is assigned a value based on its importance in the American fabric. As these rights are deprived, the value is discounted on our tax returns, by a newly created IRS form. Here are some possible examples:
MARRIAGE: 35%
MILITARY SERVICE: 8%
ADOPTING CHILDREN: 15% (currently only an issue in Florida, so only gay Florida residents are eligible.)
EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES: 9%
PRIVATE SECTOR EMPLOYMENT: 11%
HOUSING CHOICE: 16%
HOSPITAL VISITATION EQUALITY: 7%
ESTATE EQUALITY: 7%
The following discounts are available only in the communities where applicable:
LOCAL GOVERNMENT EMPLOYMENT: 11%
TEACHING: 16%
LACK OF HATE CRIME PROTECTION: 9%
These are only examples. There could, of course, be more.
People would qualify for the discounts by filling out a simple IRS form where they would simply:
A) Declare they are gay;
B) Check off the discounts for which they are eligible;
C) Apply the discounts to their federal, state and local income taxes;
D) Calculate similar discounts to their local property taxes;
E) Calculate the total, then enter it on a line on their 1040 form to be deducted from their tax obligation.
No further proof or documentation would be required.
Critics might argue that it would be possible for some dishonest heterosexuals to claim they are gay, simply to get the tax advantages. I find this difficult to believe. But even if it happened, it would serve only as a balance, considering the enormous number of closet cases who continue to try to pass themselves off as straight.
This is just a starting point, but, like all IRS codes, I believe it could have the potential to develop into an entire bookshelf of long overdue tax breaks.
Now, let's calculate the cost.
Assuming the standard 10% number for the nation's gay population, we get 30 million people. Realizing that gays and lesbians have higher average salaries, we're looking at taxable income well in excess of one trillion dollars. Given that gays and lesbians have fewer average deductions, you're looking at taxable gross income of about $900 billion dollars. Once you calculate a conservative federal tax rate of 23%, plus state and local taxes, then apply the SODA deductions you're probably looking at tax losses of about $250 Billion.
That's $250,000,000,000.
That should close a few thousand schools, stop construction of a few highways, and shut down a few dozen federal agencies.
I think people might start to notice, and might decide there isn't that much wrong with same sex marriage and equal rights protection.
After all... neither Massachusetts nor Canada have ceased to exist yet. And I think most people would rather live in either place than ANY part of Kansas or Mississippi.
